Saturday, 19 February 2011
Pride and Prejudice - just another love story?
What I like about Pride and Prejudice is that it is not simply a book about love. Money matters are at the heart of it. We have a group of women who depend on marrying well to guarantee their financial security. Mrs Bennet is keenly aware of her responsibility to find wealthy husbands for her daughters as she cannot make them financially secure herself. Mr Bennet seems incapable of grasping the urgency of the matter, and keeps to his library rather than seeing his daughters wed.
Austen is at pains to point out how annoying Mrs Bennet is and how tiresome the daughters find her. However, it cannot escape our notice that Lizzy's affections for Darcy changed as soon as she sees his big estate in Derbyshire and she jokingly admits to Jane that she must date her falling in love with Darcy from that point.
In fact, she does indeed fall in love with a wealthy man, and does, in fact, exactly what her mother would have wanted her to do. Perhaps the years of listening to her mother's plots for marrying them off has subliminally effected her. In this way, Austen shows herself to be very practical and not at all like the fairytale romance novelist that some readers consider her to be.
Charlotte Lucas, another clever female character, is similarly practical when it comes to affairs of the heart and secures her independance in the world, through matrimony, all be it a less than perfect union. Jane too marries a financially secure man with whom she has fallen in love. Indeed, she is so good, how could Austen deny her that? It is only Lydia, the youngest daughter who broke with all the social norms of the day, and ran away to live with Wickham outside of wedlock, who is unfortunate enough to be bestowed with an impoverished husband. It is clear that Austen punishes her for her unruly behaviour and for disgracing her family.
So, if we consider what advice Pride and Prejudice holds for young women, it is clear that Austen is nothing of not pragmatic: make sure you fall in love with someone who is wealthy, if you want a happy life, the happiest life.
What I love about the novel is that the more you read it, the more you see in it and the more you understand how comlicated the text really is.
Austen is at pains to point out how annoying Mrs Bennet is and how tiresome the daughters find her. However, it cannot escape our notice that Lizzy's affections for Darcy changed as soon as she sees his big estate in Derbyshire and she jokingly admits to Jane that she must date her falling in love with Darcy from that point.
In fact, she does indeed fall in love with a wealthy man, and does, in fact, exactly what her mother would have wanted her to do. Perhaps the years of listening to her mother's plots for marrying them off has subliminally effected her. In this way, Austen shows herself to be very practical and not at all like the fairytale romance novelist that some readers consider her to be.
Charlotte Lucas, another clever female character, is similarly practical when it comes to affairs of the heart and secures her independance in the world, through matrimony, all be it a less than perfect union. Jane too marries a financially secure man with whom she has fallen in love. Indeed, she is so good, how could Austen deny her that? It is only Lydia, the youngest daughter who broke with all the social norms of the day, and ran away to live with Wickham outside of wedlock, who is unfortunate enough to be bestowed with an impoverished husband. It is clear that Austen punishes her for her unruly behaviour and for disgracing her family.
So, if we consider what advice Pride and Prejudice holds for young women, it is clear that Austen is nothing of not pragmatic: make sure you fall in love with someone who is wealthy, if you want a happy life, the happiest life.
What I love about the novel is that the more you read it, the more you see in it and the more you understand how comlicated the text really is.
Jane Austen's Guide to Dating - by Lauren Henderson
Contains Austens 10 principles for dating: ‘What Not to Do!’ and ‘What to do Instead!’… all gleaned from the novles of the master-writer herself. Here is a sample of chapter headings: 'If you like someone, make it clear that you do'; 'Have faith in your own instincts'; 'Don't settle - Don't marry for money, or convenience, or out of Loneliness'.... etc. and my own particular favourite: 'If your lover needs a reprimand, let him have it'.
Friday, 18 February 2011
Freedom - by Jonathan Franzen
I was expecting so much with this novel… but it didn’t live up to the hype. I think Oprah’s enthusing just made it even more disappointing. I thought the characters were quite interesting, but I couldn’t warm to Pattie. Every aspect of her life was revealed to us, yet she just came across as so mundane. Not unlike another American heroine, Scarlett O'Hara, she seemed to waste her life dreaming of one man, while longing for another. No matter how hard she tried to be a good mother, she still managed to mess up her relationship with her son. That was the most depressing part of the whole story, as it doesn't bode well for the rest of us.
As for the title of the book - well it is all too obvious. Each character is struggling to deal with all the freedom that life has thrown at them: freedom to make decisions; to love or to hate; to waste their life if they want; to mess up royally if they choose; to try and save the world or not. I must admit that the passages about conserving flora and fauna in the Appalachian Mountains were a little too detailed for my liking and slowed the plot right down.
After all the time I invested in this novel, the ending was especially unrewarding - every issue was resolved, every problem worked through. It just didn't seem believable. Must there always be a happy ending? It seemed such a cop-out. Perhaps Franzen had an eye on Hollywood and a possible film deal when finishing the book? That said, 'Freedom' was thought-provoking and, once in a while, the characters still float into my mind. By the end, I was glad to have finished it, but I will not be recommending it to my friends.
Also by Jonathan Franzen: The Corrections: A Novel
, How to Be Alone: Essays
As for the title of the book - well it is all too obvious. Each character is struggling to deal with all the freedom that life has thrown at them: freedom to make decisions; to love or to hate; to waste their life if they want; to mess up royally if they choose; to try and save the world or not. I must admit that the passages about conserving flora and fauna in the Appalachian Mountains were a little too detailed for my liking and slowed the plot right down.
After all the time I invested in this novel, the ending was especially unrewarding - every issue was resolved, every problem worked through. It just didn't seem believable. Must there always be a happy ending? It seemed such a cop-out. Perhaps Franzen had an eye on Hollywood and a possible film deal when finishing the book? That said, 'Freedom' was thought-provoking and, once in a while, the characters still float into my mind. By the end, I was glad to have finished it, but I will not be recommending it to my friends.
Also by Jonathan Franzen: The Corrections: A Novel
, How to Be Alone: Essays
To Kindle or not to Kindle… that is the question! Can I bare to give up that sensual experience whenever I pick up a book? The rasping sound of pages turning; the scent of paper and ink fresh from the printers; the pure satisfaction that is felt as, when finished, it finds a home on the shelf next to books that have gone before.
From Jane Austen’s ’Mansfield Park’ - 1957 edition:
Fanny at the window …’astonished to see Mr Crawford!’
The Private Diary of Mr. Darcy by Maya Slater
I enjoyed reading this version of the Lizzy - Darcy affair, from Darcy’s point of view, simply because I enjoy all things Austen. However, the author does add a few creative detours regarding the plot line of Pride and Prejudice, most specifically with regard to Darcy’s friendship with Lord Byron. This idea is quite interesting. As Darcy and Bingley did mix in the same society as the infamous poet, it is entirely probable that they may have known each other. They certainly both were uncommonly fond of their sisters, although Byron, perhaps, took that sentiment to extremes, one might say.
However, I cannot allow the idea that Darcy was 'tinkering' with the girl from below stairs in his bedroom, while Lizzy and Jane slept a few bedrooms away in theirs, during their stay in Netherfield. It is shocking even to consider! But, undoubtedly, the temptation to write a few passionate, period 'love scenes' for Darcy was obviously too great to resist.
Yet, perhaps, Darcy would have been a man of the world, although I think his distaste for Wickham's wild behaviour while at college, would seem to suggest that he was above such clandestine activity and in his friend's house too! Still, it was interesting to revisit Austen's story from a different perspective, especially noting when first Darcy began to fall for Lizzy and how he was wonderfully oblivious to Caroline Bennet's obvious (and desperate) attempts to flirt with him. This was particularly enjoyable and clever too, as it was somewhat reminiscent of Austen's tongue in cheek style. It was wonderfully pleasing to see what Darcy could not see, knowing, as we do, how Caroline desired him for a husband. He is tantalizingly close, but just out of her grasp. Poor Caroline!
This is not a serious book, but rather a bit of fun between reads, and for that I recommend it to all Darcy fans and deserving friends!
The Private Diary of Mr. Darcy: A Novel
The Jane Austen Book Club by Karen Joy Fowler
There is just so much of interest for the Jane Austen fan in this novel. Every character, every plotline, mirrors one created by Jane Austen.
So, if the character hosting the book club is reading Pride and Prejudice, say, you can be sure that her personal circumstances are similar to those of Lizzy Bennet etc. It happens every time. There are many, many Austen echoes running through the novel. Even some of the characters names come from the original texts. (I wont give all the references away - half the fun is discovering the little nods to Austen yourself!)
It was great fun seeing how Karen Joy Fowler managed to turn the stories inside out, to make them fit together; to propel them into the modern period.
For that alone, I found it most enjoyable. It was cleverly done and most of the time I didn’t find it overly-contrived or laboured.
This book contained a wonderful array of characters, each dealing with their own set of problems and struggling to keep on top of things. Mothers, daughters, brothers and fathers - they are all here. But above all, this is a book about friendship and how a group of strangers come together because of their interest in Jane Austen.
To truly love or appreciate this book, you need to love, or at least know, the works of Jane Austen. Otherwise, so much is overlooked. I’d happily recommend it to Austenites… but to anyone else, I might suggest looking at Austen herself first, before reading.
It was great fun seeing how Karen Joy Fowler managed to turn the stories inside out, to make them fit together; to propel them into the modern period.
For that alone, I found it most enjoyable. It was cleverly done and most of the time I didn’t find it overly-contrived or laboured.
This book contained a wonderful array of characters, each dealing with their own set of problems and struggling to keep on top of things. Mothers, daughters, brothers and fathers - they are all here. But above all, this is a book about friendship and how a group of strangers come together because of their interest in Jane Austen.
To truly love or appreciate this book, you need to love, or at least know, the works of Jane Austen. Otherwise, so much is overlooked. I’d happily recommend it to Austenites… but to anyone else, I might suggest looking at Austen herself first, before reading.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)